Alright, I am going to go out on a
limb here and compare the rise and fall of Grendel to the rise and fall of Jeb
Bush. I know it sounds like a stretch, but I really think that I have some
compelling arguments. (Now, I don’t mean to imply that Jeb is a descendant of Cain’s
clan, but if you come to that conclusion on your own, more power to ya).
Even people that don’t necessarily
like or agree with Grendel feel sympathy for him, and the same thing can be
said for Jeb. We have talked several times in class about how the readers are
supposed to feel some amount of compassion for Grendel. He is lonely and
misunderstood, and ultimately just wants to be accepted by everyone. If Grendel
had ever expressed this to Jeb, I like to think that Jeb’s response would have been “Same.” Throughout—but especially near the end of—Jeb’s candidacy, there has
been an air of both loneliness and misunderstanding in the way Jeb was
represented by the media. People booed at things he said on stage, and during
the North Carolina, not many people seemed to agree with his policies. His poll
numbers were so low in fact, that people who didn’t even agree with him started
saying that they just wanted to give him a hug.
Grendel also really loved his
mother. Though at some times it seems that he is a bit put off by her, it is
still apparent through much of the text that Grendel is a mama’s boy. Jeb too,
loves his mother, and said as much during the North Carolina Debate. He said
that he felt that he “won the lottery” when he was born and saw his mom’s face.
Though she loved him, Grendel’s mother would also occasionally look at him in a
way that would make him feel that he was alone, obscene, and separated from her.
One has to wonder if Jeb now feels a similar way.
Grendel also changed a lot as he
aged. When he was young he was innocent and curious, and fought against his
nature as best he could, and it can be argued that Jeb went though a similar process.
It should come as a surprise to no one that the Bush family is quite wealthy,
and that they tend operate in within a pretty elite circle. They hold powerful
positions, and marry powerful, equally elite people. Naturally, Jeb would have
been expected to follow suit. Instead, when he was in college, Jeb decided to
study abroad in Mexico, where it just so happens that he met a girl and fell in
love. Against the wishes of his fam-bam, he refused to come home until she was
allowed to come with him (this is super sweet and probably my favorite thing
about him). When he was young, Jeb rebelled hard-core against his nature,
similar to Grendel. However as he aged, Jeb found his natural calling hard to
resist, and eventually joined in the ranks of the men before him, and became a
presidential candidate for the Republican Party. Like Grendel, this change soon
led to his brief and frightening reign of terror, before he ultimately dropped dead
out of the race.
If you had asked me yesterday if I thought there were similarities between Grendel and Jeb Bush, I would have laughed. I'm actually sitting over here laughing right now because it's such an off the wall comparison. But I think the point you make is valid. From the little I know about Jeb Bush, he had a bad reputation from the very beginning of the race. This wasn't particularly because of his political stance but more because people looked at him and said, "Here comes another Bush." I believe this view shares similarities with how the Danes saw Grendel. Instead of considering him as a creature with thoughts, opinions, and feelings, they just looked at him and went, "Monster!!! Arrrrrghhhh!!!" His association with the creatures he descended from instigated the Danes to see him as bad, just like Jeb's association with George automatically turned people against him.
ReplyDeleteI am so glad you made this comparison. It makes perfect sense the way you explained it. And plus, it cracks me up. Jeb's campaign was so filled with secondhand embarrassment and I get that feeling for Grendel's reign of terror at Heorot. The part of your argument that compared the feelings of sympathy both Grendel and Jeb(!) inspire was spot on. The two are not completely defenseless in the same way (Grendel has skin that can't be harmed by swords, Jeb was subject to bullying from Donald Trump), but the feelings of sympathy are there nonetheless.
ReplyDelete