Zero to Hero: Monster
Battles Through the Ages
Ezra Pound believed that time was cyclical. As depicted in his
Cantos, events are
constantly reoccurring and tropes tend to reappear throughout
history. We can see this firsthand when looking at the biblical tale
of Noah and the great flood that wiped out most of humanity, a story
that has its origins in the Babylonian epic Atrahasis.
It seems that many tales took their lead from Sumerian, Babylonian,
Greek and Roman mythology, the Anglo-Saxxon story of Beowulf
being no exception. Beowulf, a Geatish hero, resembles the Greek hero
Heracles in multiple fashions, but the moment I will be focusing on
is Beowulf's fight with Grendel mirroring Heracles' fight against the
Nemean Lion.
Starting with the arrival of Beowulf in the Danes, we already see a
similarity to Heracles: both heroes are foreigners, coming from
another land to solve a monster issue. Even their motivations for
setting out on such quests aren't too far removed; both are driven by
a debt that needs to be paid (not to mention a bonus of heroic glory
on the side). Heracles was atoning for the murder of his first wife
by being the glorified errand boy of King Eurystheus; shipped off to
Nemea to conquer a beast invulnerable to weaponry. Beowulf is in a
similar boat, sailing across the sea to defeat the murderous Grendel
whose hide was so tough “that no blade on earth, no blacksmith's
art / could ever damage their demon opponent” (Haney 802-803). Upon
arrival, both men are welcomed into their respective lands not out of
warm intentions springing from the heart, but because they might
prove useful in solving a pretty monstrous problem.
So what do these men do when finally confronted by the most dangerous
of beasts? Throw their weapons aside of course (with an added perk of
no clothing from Beowulf). It's hand-to-hand combat for these guys,
nothing else. The reasoning behind this choice of action is solid:
Heracles and Beowulf quickly processed that fighting their respective
enemies with sword or spear would only be cumbersome since nothing
can pierce the monsters' hides. And to top off both these heroes
incredible displays of masculinity, Grendel gets to have his arm
ripped off by Beowulf while the Nemean Lion is choked out by those
chiseled arms of Heracles.
The incredible similarities between these two heroes isn't
particularly surprising seeing as all heroes tend to follow the same
roads to heroism. It's standard for a Greek or Roman hero to be
birthed into an aristocratic or noble family where they can learn the
the arts of swordsmanship, archery, wrestling, and speech craft. Each
of these activities were viewed as luxuries and therefore not
generally doled out to the common rabble in an aristocratic society.
These tropes are central to the establishment of a hero not only
because they provide all the necessary mechanisms for battling demons
and rescuing damsels in distress, but also because they drive the
story to an inspirational (if not classist) ending.
I honestly hadn’t think about Hercules when doing my blog, the similarities between them is astonishing. The only Hercules or Heracles I know is the Disney version, but once I read your blog and looked up what the actual story of Heracles it all made sense. I completely agree about your comparison, I think the unifying factor of this comparison is their super human strength, whom other besides Heracles and Beowulf kill monsters with their bare hands. Lastly I like how you included “chiseled arms of Hercules” it actually reminded me of Grendel when he kept on talking about Beowulf and how strong he was.
ReplyDeleteI honestly hadn’t think about Hercules when doing my blog, the similarities between them is astonishing. The only Hercules or Heracles I know is the Disney version, but once I read your blog and looked up what the actual story of Heracles it all made sense. I completely agree about your comparison, I think the unifying factor of this comparison is their super human strength, whom other besides Heracles and Beowulf kill monsters with their bare hands. Lastly I like how you included “chiseled arms of Hercules” it actually reminded me of Grendel when he kept on talking about Beowulf and how strong he was.
ReplyDelete