Wednesday, April 6, 2016
Mina Harker: Dracula's Bride?
Throughout Dracula, one character remains a constant.
That would be Mina Murry Harker, wife of Jonathan Harker and final near victim
of Dracula’s spree of evil. In the book and most portrayals, Mina is a school
teacher, and only connected to the events by friendship or her husband. Yet
when Dracula forces her to drink his blood and start to change, she takes
center stage, locates and guides the men to him, all the while remaining
determined to help in any way she can to get vengeance for Lucy and put Dracula
down for good. Most adaptations of the story stick to this basic framework,
with some, such as F.W. Mearneau’s Nosferatu
having her be the one to ultimately end Dracula’s reign of terror by
sacrificing herself to lure the count into sunlight, and others, such as Alan
Moore’s The League of Extraordinary
Gentlemen, have her getting into adventures after Dracula’s death, either
with or without Jonathan, and generally just being cool. In my opinion, these
versions of Mina are solid role models for girls, despite some of the sexist
leanings some of the stories have, due to Mina’s overall noble and kind nature,
yet having an iron resolve that allows her to journey into battle with a
villain who, let’s be honest, raped her, and stand against forces that any
human would be terrified to face, and still feel some measure of sympathy
toward someone who is pure evil. So why is it that, in most modern versions of
the story, Mina is made into a reincarnation of Dracula’s wife and falls in
love with him, or just plain out falls in love with him? I seriously don’t get
the appeal of this, especially since most times I’ve seen it, it is done
extremely poorly. Seriously, the Coppola film might be one of the earliest
versions where this happened, but I’ve seen it so many other times that it is
ridiculous. In the NBC Dracula series, this was basically the main plot, the
“sequel” Dracula the Un-dead by Bram
Stoker’s great-grandnephew Dacre has Quincy Harker’s father turn out to have
been Dracula along with Dracula actually turning out be a good guy hunting a
vampire Elizabeth Bathory, and even the animated film The Batman vs. Dracula has the female lead turn out to be a
reincarnation of Dracula’s wife. I have to question why this is so popular.
Reading the text, there is only one moment that indicates an actual connection
between the two that doesn’t come off as disturbing or rapey. It’s when Mina
says she feels sorry for Dracula for his curse, which she follows up by saying
that she feels sorry for him just because of how much being a vampire must
suck. Considering we don’t know how Dracula was turned in the first place,
Mina’s sympathy could be completely misplaced, and Dracula could just be evil.
But even still, that one moment doesn’t explain the obsession with putting the
two together. The moments that go against that scene include Dracula raping and
murdering Lucy, torturing Jonathan, killing untold numbers of people over the
centuries, killing babies, beating women, pretty much raping Mina, and a number
of other crimes. Yet, somehow, this one scene seems to have become the source
for making the two a dedicated couple, despite the only physical interaction
between the two being a rape scene. Like I previously questioned, what is with
the desire to make us sympathize with character’s that are pure evil? It ruins
the mystique around them, and makes them into less compelling characters for
me.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment