Subtle, something delicate or precise as to be difficult to
analyze or describe, making use of clever and indirect methods to achieve
something (Webster). This is a word that I would never use to describe Dead until Dark book series and the
horrid TV spin-off True Blood both of
which take any subtlety that could be and burns it like Bill at breakfast.
The novel makes a better attempt at subtlety in some places
while in other place it derails and crashes. Some of the positive uses of subtlety
in the book are by giving hints about Sam being a werewolf/dog, the killer’s identity,
and how Vampire blood could be addictive, but that’s about the end of it. Other
than these few points the book is pretty on the nose about what means what and
how the characters are feeling by having the characters narrate their own feelings.
The worst example of the negative subtlety in the novel is when Sookie and Bill
have sex in the graveyard after she thought he was dead. (Also am I the only
one who thinks sex in a graveyard is both creepy and really disgusting) In most
romantic novels a person orgasming is described as the character being
transported to another realm of existence, feeling euphoric and understanding
what it means to be in love. But in this terrible novel this moment is summed
up in just three words “Suddenly I came”, how romantic (Dead Until Dark). You can
just feel the author just violently beating you in the head saying “Do you get
it”. No matter how I bash the book the show did so much worse.
"You just spent all day submerged in the ground, lets plow!"
The only subtle part of the show True Blood, is the actually catchy and fitting opening song called Bad Things. In the opening the song
plays over stock footage of decaying animals, the KKK, images that represent Louisiana,
and religion. Now some of you might think that this is not really subtle,
showing the main themes of the show before the episode even starts but compared
to the rest of this train wreck this is godly. Some examples of this are the “pie
scene”, and any scene with Sam. During the scenes with Sam there are many hints
that he is a dog from showing a picture of a dog in his office, Tara saying Sam
is “Like a dog with a bone”, and Bill calling him a mutt. This and the fact he
always showed up in his dog form every time Sookie turns him down or tells him
to leave, nice.
Finally we get to the pie scene, where pie is mistreated just
like the audience. The scene has Sookie slowly eating the last pie that Gran
had made before she died, to the tune of a southern hymn. This scene is supposed
to show Sookie grieving for her grandmother, but comes off as forced and heavy
handed and almost comical. (It also quickly transitions from this scene to all
of the main characters having sex). So
the both book and the TV spin-off show a lot of southern pride, racism and a lot
of unnecessary sex, but little to no subtlety and it clearly shows.
How we all feel after watching the show.
Yeah, I don't think the book or show are subtle at all either, and sex in a graveyard is disgusting. But on top of that, I also really thought the book dropped the ball in terms of subtlety when Harris used language like "penetrate" to discuss Bill's fangs going into Sookie's throat, and describing that vampire Elv...I mean, "Bubba" and his taste for cat blood right after the death of Sookie's pet cat. But most importantly, I'm surprised we haven't gotten to the adaptation of the part of the plotline where we find out Sam is basically the Pokémon Ditto, but I digress. I mean, even the pie scene doesn't really measure up to Sam's "Oh, you know that dog visiting your house? That's me!" schtick in terms of subtlety or lack thereof. Maybe it's because I am a cat person, but I don't know if Sam shapeshifting like that is wise.
ReplyDelete